Option Price Homogeneity and Convexity
Changing strike tests a different property from scaling spot and strike together. Convexity in strike follows from the European call payoff in a consistent one-expiry model. Homogeneity under joint scaling also depends on how the underlying dynamics and other inputs scale. Separate tests help locate whether a pricing engine breaks a payoff identity or embeds a scale assumption.
How it works
For the same maturity, a European call payoff is convex in strike. Discounted averaging preserves that property, which supplies a direct consistency test for model prices. Homogeneity in spot and strike is a separate property. It follows when scaling those inputs scales the underlying payoff across scenarios and leaves other model inputs suitably unchanged.
Worked example
With evenly spaced strikes, calls at 90, 100 and 110 are quoted at 14, 8 and 3. The call butterfly costs 14 − 2 × 8 + 3 = 1. If the last price were 1 instead, the butterfly would cost −1 even though its terminal payoff is nonnegative.
Validation and limitations
Use quotes with consistent maturity, country conventions and bid–ask treatment. In scaling tests also rescale fixed cash inputs when the mathematical argument calls for it. A model with cash dividends or a fixed additive shift can fail spot-strike homogeneity for a valid reason.
Further reading
- The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities
Fischer Black and Myron Scholes · PDF
- The Range of Traded Option Prices
Mark Davis and David Hobson · Author PDF