No-Arbitrage Smile Extrapolation
Once the liquid strikes end, the assumed tails of the option price curve can dominate the value of a far out-of-the-money option. The Benaim–Dodgson–Kainth method attaches smooth tails to a fitted core. A reviewer checks that option prices stay convex and, for multiple expiries, that the slices are mutually consistent. Matching the core and its derivatives alone can still leave a butterfly with a negative price.
How it works
The Benaim–Dodgson–Kainth method attaches parametric tails to a reliable price core. The low wing is fitted in puts and the high wing in calls. Matching values and derivatives at each join limits discontinuities, while the available quotes leave the far-wing decay and many tail-sensitive prices open.
Worked example
In the report, several extrapolations reproduce the same five central quotes. At strike 360, fitted calls range from about 0.00462 to 0.05727. A stressed wing still matches the value, slope and curvature at its join yet prices a 124–125–126 butterfly at −0.002232. Re-fitting the tail removes that local violation.
Validation and limitations
Check option price bounds and convexity across the entire extrapolated slice, not only at fitted strikes. For multiple expiries, also check calendar consistency at comparable moneyness. Tail moment assumptions and pricing-measure exercise probabilities should be documented separately.
A worked example
Two price curves agree on the quoted strikes from 80 to 120. Beyond the last quote, they assign different prices to the same call option.
| Call at strike 180 | Present value |
|---|---|
| Matched power-law wing | 2.65 |
| Uniform continuation | 0.96 |
What to check
- Match the price, slope and curvature where the core joins each wing.
- Test price bounds, monotonicity and convexity away from the joins.
- When several expiries are involved, check consistency across maturities.
Further reading
- Arbitrage-Free SVI Volatility Surfaces
Jim Gatheral and Antoine Jacquier · PDF
- The Moment Formula for Implied Volatility at Extreme Strikes
Roger Lee · PDF
- OpenGamma Strata implementation documentation